Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jack's avatar

I think nudity is one of the last remaining options for transgression and titillation, even though it's been done numerous times already. They want so bad to be a spectacle but it's not shocking anymore. Yet that's what they go with because there's nothing left to offend the safe people to offend.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

At the moment we live in an attention economy which creates this kind of race to the bottom for shock value. The hope is it is not new in human history. You read Augustine talk about his friend being forced to go and watch the gladiator games after he converted and tried to stop.

Culture goes in cycles, from overly prudish to overly excessive.

The problem now is that culture is largely divided into an artificial (and newly redefined) highly polarized "right and left" that increasingly both value a shock-jock hedonistic ethos.

Kanye has been hanging with literal neo-Nazis and spewing more of his "I love Hitler" tweets, and the left while outraged doesn't have much of a moral foundation as for many, the game was also to deconstruct ethical structures for sexual freedom while maintaining social justice principles borrowed from Christianity without any real God behind the machine giving gravitas... and furthermore have undercut their own moral efforts with a whole "party at the edge of the void" "celebrate the journey not the end" ethos. I think this has lead some to say, if that's the case, just screw it! I'm going to take over the right with this spirit of cynical nihilism to get my bag out of it, YOLO suckers!

In this environment we need artists to be those performance-art prophets of the Old Testament, who can poetically and creatively express a moral clarity against "Israel" and "Babylon"... and be willing to be ignored, mocked, or worse... but to not lose our love for people... not to give in to cynicism... but to capture our imaginations with the inventor of love again.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts